The FA Cup, the oldest national football competition in the world, has seen legendary clubs and players etch their names into history. While the competition is dominated by English talent, a select few Americans have also left their mark by winning the prestigious trophy. As of 2025, four American-born players have achieved this feat—each in their own unique era and context.
1. Julian Sturgis – 1873 (Wanderers FC)
The first American to win the FA Cup was Julian Sturgis, a name unfamiliar to many modern fans. Born in Boston, Massachusetts, Sturgis was raised in England and played for the Wanderers Football Club. In 1873, he helped his side lift the trophy, becoming the first American-born player to win English football’s most storied competition.
2. Tim Howard – 2004 (Manchester United)
More than a century later, Tim Howard became the second American to win the FA Cup. The New Jersey native joined Manchester United in 2003 and quickly made an impact. In 2004, Howard played a vital role in United’s campaign, culminating in a 3-0 win over Millwall in the final. He remains one of the most accomplished American goalkeepers in European football.
3. Chris Richards – 2025 (Crystal Palace)
In one of the most remarkable underdog runs in FA Cup history, Chris Richards helped Crystal Palace stun Manchester City 1-0 in the 2025 final. The Alabama-born defender was instrumental in Palace’s defense throughout the tournament and played a full match in the final at Wembley. It was Palace’s first-ever major trophy, and Richards became the third American to win the Cup.
4. Matt Turner – 2025 (Crystal Palace)
While Matt Turner did not feature in the final, his contributions to Crystal Palace’s cup run were vital in earlier rounds. The U.S. Men’s National Team goalkeeper was part of the winning squad, and his involvement throughout the tournament earns him a place on the list of American FA Cup winners.
Conclusion
From 19th-century pioneers to modern-day champions, these four Americans have achieved glory in one of the most revered competitions in world football. As the presence of U.S. talent continues to grow in Europe, future names will no doubt be added to this exclusive club.